MENU
- Home
- Overview
- Attorneys
- Practice Areas
- Firm News
- Blog
- Contact
When it comes to car accidents, gathering accurate information about what happened is vital for determining fault and liability. In recent years, black boxes have come to the forefront because they can offer indisputable evidence. So what are black boxes, and what role do they play when determining liability in car accidents?
A black box, also known as an Event Data Recorder (EDR), is a device installed in many modern vehicles. Its primary function is to capture specific data related to the vehicle’s performance and operation during events like collisions. Similar to black boxes used in airplanes, these devices provide insights into the circumstances leading to an accident:
Black boxes are typically integrated into a vehicle’s electronic control modules and sensors. When certain criteria are met—such as a sudden deceleration or airbag deployment—the EDR activates and records data for a brief time period. The information is saved to the device’s memory, where it can later be retrieved using specialized tools.
Black box data is often used as evidence in car accident investigations, insurance claims, and legal proceedings. The information can clarify disputes over fault and responsibility, as it provides an objective account of the vehicle’s behavior at the time of the crash.
Courts may accept black box data as admissible evidence, but the data alone is not always sufficient to determine fault. It must be combined with other evidence, such as witness statements, road conditions, and physical damage to the vehicles.
The ownership of black box data can be a complicated matter, as laws vary by state. Generally, the data belongs to the vehicle’s owner, which means permission is typically required to access the information. Law enforcement or insurance companies may need to obtain a warrant or the owner’s consent before downloading the data.
In some cases, vehicle manufacturers may also have access to the data, especially if it is collected as part of regular maintenance or diagnostic procedures. It is important for vehicle owners to be aware of the privacy implications and understand their rights concerning black box data.
The duration for which black box data remains available depends on the vehicle and the circumstances of the event. In most cases, the data is overwritten after a certain period or after the occurrence of another event. For example, if a new crash occurs, the previous data may be lost.
To preserve the recorded data after an accident, the EDR should be downloaded as soon as possible. This often requires the assistance of a qualified technician who has the necessary tools and software to access the information.
While black boxes provide valuable information, there are some limitations to consider:
Given these limitations, black box data is typically used as a component of a broader investigation rather than as the sole determinant of fault.
The Wilmington car accident lawyers at Jacobs & Crumplar, P.A. have experience with car accident cases and our team understands how to leverage black box evidence. For a free initial consultation, call our New Castle and Millsboro, Delaware, offices at 302-656-5445 or contact us online. We proudly serve clients in New Castle County, Kent County, and Sussex County.